Two Historical Novels on the Leading Ladys of France: Marie Antoinette and Athenais

Marie Antoinette: The Last Queen of France

There are few subjects that divide historians as much as Marie Antoinette – who probably, incidentally, never actually said "let them eat cake". Those of the anti-monarchical, pro-Revolutionary, or just plain misogynist school, are convinced that she was a nymphomaniac, traitorous bad mother with no redeeming qualities whatsoever. Those of the royalist school by contrast, along with the odd feminist who's tired of reading the same slurs again and again about powerful women, tend to defend her as purer than the driven snow, well-meaning, if, they have to admit, a little out of touch with the realities of France.

Evelyne Lever, a prominent French historian, with the benefit of some papers and facts only relatively recently available, has trawled through the archives, reasonably weighed the facts (it seems – she has fewer obvious angles than most writers I've read on this subject), and, perhaps unsurprisingly, come down somewhere in the middle. No, Marie Antoinette almost certainly wasn't faithful to the king (although this will probably never be proved with complete certainty); no, she never sacrificed the interests of her native Austria to the land into which she'd (so unhappily) married into; no, she never developed any realistic political sense. But there were entirely understandable, if not defensible, reasons for all of those failings.

First, Antonia, as she was known in her birth family, was not properly brought up for the royal duties she was almost certain to perform. Her mother, Empress Maria Theresa, might have been an early "Superwoman", almost singlehandedly running an empire while giving birth to a dozen children and seeing nine (exceptional for the time) growing into adulthood, and she might have ensured her daughter learnt courtly manners, but she didn't see to her education in politics, ethics or simply how to get along with people when more than a winning smile was needed.

Read more of the book review here, or read more Marie Antoinette: The Last Queen of Francehere.


Athenais: The Life of Louis XIV's Mistress, the Real Queen Of France

There's no doubt about the top position that a woman could reach in France in the time of Louis XIV, the Sun King, at least by her own efforts. That supreme goal was to be the king's official maitresse en titre, the king's official mistress. Louis in his long reign had just three. It is the middle of these, Athenais, or to give her proper due, the Marquise de Montespan, about whom Lisa Hilton has chosen to write a biography, titled "The Real Queen of France".

As that title suggests, Hilton admires Athenais;she's more than a little seduced by this powerful character, but then given all of the assassination that the marquise's character has endured – in her lifetime and afterwards – perhaps as a corrective that's no bad thing. We can do with positive, approving accounts of powerful women – particularly those who've started from practically nowhere and risen, determinedly and creatively, to the very top.

But that's not a view of her generally shared by either contemporaries or later historians. The famous letter writer Madam de Sevigne called her "the Torrent", or "Circe", and her character's been blackened by her alleged involvement in the "The Affair of the Poisons" – a murky, widespread case of alleged sorcery, witchcraft and poisoning that stretched through all of French society, from the bottom to the centre of Versailles itself. (Hilton convincingly acquits Athenaisof serious involvement in the case – she might indeed have used love potions on the king, but wild claims of black masses and poisoning attempts don't, she says, hold up to any sort of scrutiny, and can be traced to political machinations behind the investigation.)

Read more of the book review here, or get a copy of Athenais: The Life of Louis XIV's Mistress, the Real Queen Of Francehere.